With humble apologies to Stuart Smalley/Al Franken, I will continue my spring cleaning here.
I don’t think anyone really hates me for having come through the hard times that I have because to have my life as it is right now, one would have to be willing to have lived all that came before – from day one. Our society has such a perverted view of what life after tragedy should look like that too many of us feel we have failed if we haven’t muscled our way through the bleak days to that happily ever after of the movies. If we don’t write a book or give inspirational talks in high schools and churches or if our lives haven’t morphed into block-busting films with Julia Roberts playing us and riding off into a CGI sunset with Brad Pitt or Tom Hanks, well then perhaps we just didn’t try hard enough. Dangit! Our lives just aren’t near as great as they were before when we used to be able to perform concertos and write inspirational literature in between our steady gigs as sex kitten wives and practically perfect in every way moms. What? That wasn’t you either? Good to know.
This fantasy life that doesn’t even exist on television anymore still seems to be the ideal we superimpose over women who appear to have all that we don’t. I was one of those envious types long, long ago in my pre-wife days. An especially good friend seemed to have the kind of life – wonderful husband and marriage. Perfect figure. Everyone loved her. Or that’s what it looked it standing on the sidelines. I imagine her version would not match my imagination. She is remarried now and truly happy. Her first husband is in prison for the murder of their son.
Change is one of those givens of existence that is inescapable, and yet it is one of the things that most surprises us when it happens. The givens in life have a way of catching us off guard and upending absolutely everything because we all seem to think that we are the exceptions to the rule. Death is the biggest given of all, impacting every fiber of our being and reverberating out like water ripples from a stone breaking a calm reflective pool. With time and hard work, most of us fight our way back only to discover we are not the same. Some embrace the changes. Some lament them. Others crumble.
Regardless, change in any form is not welcomed by many of us. Growing up, I was the fat sister. My two younger sisters were very thin with tiny waists and perky breasts whereas I was flat-chested with tummy rolls and thighs that rubbed together so much that the inseam of my pants wore thin from the friction. Eventually with a lot of work and self-reflection all that changed and my sisters have never really been okay with this even though I was merely normal weight as they were. Now that they are both heavier than I am, they are even less pleased. I get told to “eat” a lot and am scoffed at when I decline things that they both know I can’t eat because of my allergies. I seldom visit now that I am not inspected and found wanting. I am too thin. My hair was too blond the last time. This particular change is now closing in on two decades, and it still upsets their apple carts because it’s threatening. Whenever the original terms of any relationship are changed, the party not in control will probably not like it and let it be known.
A while back a very wonderful woman I met through the widow board expressed her sorrow over not being able to give back some of the wisdom and comfort she had received there to newer members. She felt that because she was remarried, her words were disregarded. She was no longer perceived as a fellow widow. She was all better now. But the truth is more complicated. When widowed people meet other widowed people it is their mutual loss that brings them together on a common ground called grief. A widowed person then who moves on, whether it is into a new relationship or simply a new way of living with grief as a component rather than a driving force, is changing the nature of the friendship or acquaintanceship. Those not ready, or inclined, to move on will feel threatened and even betrayed.
One of the most insulting things that occurs when a widowed person falls in love and decides to marry again is the perception all around that he/she is now officially “over it”. The late spouse is just a blip on the road, seldom thought of and certainly no longer mourned. This reaction is most noticeable in friends and family. Most of whom are relieved because the new relationship frees them from worry and feeling responsible for the widowed person. (Widowed people face a certain amount of kid-gloving that frankly made me feel like I’d been brain-injured. People spoke to me more slowly and gave me these long doe-eyed looks that were actually a little scary.) There can be a certain amount of resentment from those who believe that the widowed person’s love for their departed one was not quite up to Romeo & Juliet standards – it’s not just Hindus who think a crispy fried widow is the best kind of widow but, by and large, the sense that all is now “normal” and “okay” again is palpable.
And then there are the widowed friends/aquaintances of the widowed person. There are two camps. Remarried widowed who know what is about to come and are sad to see it happen but can’t quite put voice to the marginalization, even ostracization, that they know is coming having been through it. Being married again, a widow loses status and voice within the “community” because they are no longer perceived as being widowed. In the other camp are the widowed still. Dating or not. Interested in marrying again or not. The common view is that you are a widow only as long as you are alone and suffering. Heavy emphasis on suffering. Heavier emphasis on alone. They don’t give merit badges for number of lonely years out from the loss that one spends with degree of difficulty added for manner of death and number of children left behind to be dealt with – or maybe they do, and I just wasn’t widowed long enough to earn one. The remarried are not allowed to use their previous experiences with grief, the lonliness and the despair as entry into the widowed world. Remarriage has cured them of that and in doing so wiped those memories away.
Mourning is equated with love. Remarriage is equated with not having loved at all or been with one’s “soulmate”. A particularly vicious idea, it attempts to negate everything that is true about the remarried’s previous marriage in order to make another widow feel better about their own situation. It reduces everything to some sort of contest with shifting rules of dubious origin. Hardly helpful and rebuffing of any attempts for reasonable dialogue. This is especially true of what happens to people who remarry within the first two years of widowhood. Even though half of all widowed people under 55 will remarry and many of them within the first two years, they are still regarded as anomalous freaks, or worse, by their peers.
Will was my first husband. He is Katy’s father. I loved him. I spent years watching him dissolve in front of me with very little sympathy or emotional support – mainly, I now know, because we are not taught how to help people when they are dying or their loved ones. I didn’t even have him to share the gut-wrenching moments with due to his incapacitation. I was alone. And like Atlas supporting the world around us on my breaking soul. I haven’t forgotten a moment. A day doesn’t go by where I don’t remember things. It would be easy to call up the tears, curl up in a ball and sob until I couldn’t breathe. It is a grave insult to me and to his memory to suggest that I am “all better now”, and yet it happens.
In our society we are quick to pronounce wellness and fitness. Remove a child from an abusive situation and be baffled by the lack of improvement in behavior. Clap a band or two around someone’s stomach and wonder why they still have food issues or body image problems. Remarry after being widowed and expect them to have forgotten what it was like to have irretrievably lost part of the cores of their beings.
The gamut of life’s problems parade before you when you are a teacher. The longer the time in the classroom, the more you will see. After Will was sick and then again after he died, I began to look at the children and their families in a new way. I saw that most difficulties stemmed from a lack of communication and a refusal to take responsibility. Neither are easy skills to master, and so I became the teacher that the other teachers loathed because I gave more rope instead of just enough to tie into nooses. People come to their epiphanies in their own good time. Little by little I learn that this approach should be extended beyond my first limited use of it.
I am not happy because of what the scale says. I am not happy because I have remarried. People do think that about me however. I am happy because I choose to be. Every day. Because life is basically good regardless of the obstacles and pain and disappoints that can occur. And that was as true back in my caregiving/widow day as it is now. I am a work of art. A work still in progress – but my own nevertheless with all my faults and warts. And I am an example, though I don’t really try to be any more, regardless of whether some people approve of me or not. We are all examples really. We find our own mentors in life. We choose the paths we want to be on and the people who will be accompanying us. We are responsible for where we are and where we are going.
Comparing ourselves to others is a waste of time that is better spent on ourselves and the works in progress that we each are.

Most difficulties stem from a lack of communication and refusal to take responsibility – boy if that isn’t the truth. Thanks for a thoughtful post on a topic our culture tries not to think about.
I am only 8 months out, but this post really resonated with me. I am currently in that weird limbo of ‘it’s not socially acceptable to date’ but ‘you should be moving on’ fun phase of grief. I have no idea what I am doing, and I realize this comments makes very little sense, but I am very appreciative of it and look forward to coming back to it someday.
Girl – Romeo and Juliet is the worst love model ever and has become so despite Shakespeare’s intentions, which was to point out the follies of love – hence the “tragedy” designation. When I taught the play, I always made sure to emphasis that it was lack of communication and jumping to conclusions that lead to much of the tragedy. I also made a point of establishing that it was lust and not love that the two characters were in. Not surprisingly young teens didn’t really need that latter lesson pointed out. They easily saw that R and J couldn’t possibly have been motivated by love given the brief time span. Mouths of babes.
Thank you all for the comments and support. I was a bit worried that this piece might provoke offense though not enough to not publish it. Too often it is assumed that landing on your feet and maintaining an outwardly upright position after tragedy is a sign of having put the past so far in the past that you haven’t any contact with it anymore and couldn’t possibly understand others going through similar things. Myopia indeed.
Great post, Annie. I have experienced much of the same things–both with widowhood and weight loss, oddly enough. All I can say is “Amen.”
You know, I will never, ever understand why Romeo and Juliet is one of our enduring allusions to a great love. You’ve got 2 dumb young kids who don’t know anything who are married a day before they’re both dead through rash action based on incorrect assumptions and a cockamamie scheme. Now there’s a love story that’s ten kinds of awesome. Though I suppose it applies to a lot of folks. Never really tripped my trigger, though.
This is very well written and accurate. Your post makes a strong statement that I identify with.
I lack your eloquence in writing, but I expressed a similar view in one of my entries back in ’05. At that time it hadn’t yet sunk in that it wasn’t just the general public that didn’t “get it” but also other widows.
I suppose nobody can truly understand until they actually walk in another’s shoes. I suspect there are lots of “Aha” moments as widows find themselves in a new relationship that they swore would never happen to them. I know I had one of those moments. Then I understood.
Stella
Yes, yes, yes- especially the part about happiness being about you and a deliberate choice and not remarriage. I think you have articulated a big part of the reason that “the board” is no longer a place of much value for mr (and from me).
Sally
(I’m pretty sure I’m writing in short-hand here- still tired from a late night at work…)
this is a really interesting topic, I enjoyed what Rob wrote about it recently too.
other people want “us bereaved” to be better, to be happy, not just for our sakes but also because we make them uncomfortable. I don’t talk about stephen much now unless someone asks, and they usually don’t because they want to believe I’m “over the worst”.
I still cry in the car most days but I can put on my “happy” face around people. it’s just easier for all concerned.